BUCKHORN CLIFFSA preparedness field manual

Garden and Livestock · Guide

Straw vs Hay: What Each One Is, What a Bale Weighs, and What to Do with It

Hay is feed: grasses and legumes cut green and dried. Straw is the hollow stem left after a grain harvest, and it is bedding, mulch and insulation, not food. How to tell them apart at the feed store, what a bale weighs, what to check before you buy, and every job straw does on my place.

Quick facts

  • HayGrasses (timothy, orchard, brome) and legumes (alfalfa, clover), cut green and dried; animal feed
  • StrawHollow stems of wheat, oats, barley or rye left after the grain is combined; bedding and mulch
  • Tell them apartHay is green to gray-green and smells sweet; straw is gold, shiny and hollow
  • Small square baleHay 45 to 70 lb; straw 35 to 50 lb; both roughly 14 x 18 x 36 inches
  • Round bale800 to 1,500 lb; needs a tractor or a bale spear
  • Before you mulch with itAsk if the field was sprayed with a persistent herbicide (aminopyralid, clopyralid)

They sit inches apart at the feed store, they are both baled, and both are yellow-ish from ten feet away. One is food and the other is a building material. If you keep animals or a garden you will buy both, and buying the wrong one is an expensive mistake in one direction and a sick animal in the other.

HayFeedGrass and legumes, cut green
StrawBedding and mulchGrain stems after harvest
45 to 70 lbSmall hay baleStraw 35 to 50 lb
800+ lbRound baleTractor territory

Hay: the feed

Hay is a whole plant, grasses or legumes or a mix, cut while it's still green and growing, left in the field to dry to about 15 percent moisture, then raked and baled. It's cut before the seed heads form because the protein and energy are in the leaves, and both fall off fast once the plant goes to seed. Good hay is green to gray-green, smells sweet, and still has its leaves.

Grass hayTimothy, orchardgrass, brome, bermuda. The maintenance feed for horses and for adult goats, sheep and cattle that are not milking or growing. Lower protein, safer to feed free-choice.
Legume hayAlfalfa and clover. High protein and calcium, the feed for milking goats, growing kids and thin animals. Too rich as the only hay for an idle horse.
Mixed hayGrass with some alfalfa, the middle ground and what most small places buy. Ask the percentage; it changes the price and the feeding rate.
Checking a bale before you pay
  • Break one open. Green inside, sweet smell, leaves on the stems.
  • Push a hand into the middle. Warm means it was baled wet and will mold; a hot stack can catch fire.
  • Brown, gray, dusty or musty hay was rained on or stored badly. Dust is mold; horses get heaves from it.
  • Weeds, sticks, trash and baling twine in the bale mean you are paying hay price for garbage.

Straw: the leftover stem

Straw is what the combine leaves behind. Wheat, oats, barley and rye are grown for their seed heads; once those are threshed off, the hollow stems standing in the field are cut, raked and baled. There is almost no feed value in them, so straw is cheap. It makes good bedding because it's dry, hollow, springy and slow to rot.

Wheat strawis the common one, stiff and gold, the general purpose bale.
Oat strawis softer and more absorbent, my pick for bedding under animals and in nest boxes.
Barley strawhas sharp awns that get into eyes and skin; fine for mulch, not for bedding. Floated in a mesh bag it also keeps algae down in a stock tank or pond.
Rye strawis long and tough, the traditional thatch and the best for a windbreak or erosion mat.

Straw carries a little grain seed. A few wheat sprouts in the garden after mulching are normal; pull them.

Telling them apart in ten seconds

HayStraw
ColorGreen to gray-greenGold, shiny
SmellSweet, grassyDry, faint, dusty
StemsSolid, leafy, sometimes with flowersHollow tubes, no leaves
Weight, small bale45 to 70 lb35 to 50 lb
PriceTwo to four times strawCheap
JobFeedBedding, mulch, insulation

Hay feeds the horse and straw beds the stall. A horse fed straw goes hungry, and a horse bedded on alfalfa eats its bedding and gets fat.

Bales: what you are buying

A bale is a compressed, tied bundle so the stuff can be moved and stacked. The two shapes matter because they decide what equipment you need.

Small square balesTwo-string, about 14 x 18 x 36 inches, 45 to 70 lb of hay or 35 to 50 lb of straw. One person lifts them, they stack in a truck bed and a shed, and you can feed by the flake. This is what a small place buys.
Large square balesThree-string at 100 to 125 lb, or the 3 x 3 x 8 foot bales at 800 lb and up. Cheaper per ton, but one person can't lift them.
Round bales800 to 1,500 lb. The cheapest hay per ton, but they need a tractor with a spear, a feeder ring so the animals do not waste half of it, and dry storage; a round bale left out loses its outer foot to rot.

Buy hay by weight when you can. A light, loosely packed bale at the same price is less feed.

What straw does on my place

Garden mulch4 to 6 inches around tomatoes, peppers, squash and along paths. Holds water, stops weeds, keeps fruit off the dirt, and turns into soil by spring.
Animal beddingGoats, chickens, the dog house. Absorbent, warm, easy to fork out. Deep litter in the coop through winter: keep adding straw over the old, turn it, and clean out once in spring.
InsulationBales stacked around a well head, a stock tank, the north wall of the coop or a cold frame. Straw does not wick like hay and a dry bale stays a bale for a season or two.
Lawn seed coverA thin scatter over new grass seed keeps birds off and the soil damp. Thin enough to see soil through it.
Straw bale gardeningCondition a bale with water and nitrogen for two weeks, plant into the top, and grow potatoes and tomatoes where there is no soil at all.
Backstop and windbreakA stacked wall stops arrows, cuts wind across a garden bed, and slows runoff on a slope. Soiled bales go to the compost pile and finish the job there.
The herbicide question

Some hay and straw fields are sprayed with persistent broadleaf herbicides (aminopyralid, clopyralid, picloram). They pass through animals and survive composting, and mulch or manure carrying them will curl and stunt tomatoes, beans, peas and potatoes for a season or more. Before straw or manure goes on a vegetable bed, ask the grower what was sprayed. If nobody knows, plant a few bean seeds in a pot of the suspect material and watch for twisted leaves before you spread it.

Storing both

  • Off the ground, on pallets, under a roof. Ground contact rots the bottom bale and wicks moisture up the stack.
  • Hay needs air: stack with gaps, never against a wall, and never stack fresh hay tight in a closed barn. Wet hay heats and can ignite.
  • Straw is forgiving; a tarp over a pallet stack outdoors gets it through a season. Keep the tarp off the sides so air moves.
  • Mice get into both, so keep cats, set traps and keep the stack tidy.
  • Buy hay in summer when it's cut. Winter hay is the same hay at a higher price, and in a hard year there is none to buy.

Questions this answers

Tap a question for the short answer.

What is the difference between straw and hay?

Hay is food: grasses and legumes cut while green, dried in the field and baled for feed. Straw is the hollow stalk left in the field after wheat, oats, barley or rye have been combined for grain; it has almost no feed value, so it's cheap, and it's used for bedding, mulch and insulation. Hay is green and smells sweet. Straw is gold, shiny and hollow.

What is hay made of?

Grasses such as timothy, orchardgrass, brome and bermuda, legumes such as alfalfa and clover, or a mix. It is cut before the plants set seed, because feed value drops as they mature, dried to under about 15 percent moisture and baled. Alfalfa is the high-protein hay for dairy goats and growing stock; grass hay is the maintenance feed for horses and adult animals.

What is straw made of?

The stems left standing after a cereal grain is harvested. The combine takes the seed heads and leaves the straw, which is raked and baled. Wheat straw is the common one; oat straw is softer and the one I want for bedding; barley straw has stiff awns that irritate skin and eyes.

What can I use straw for?

Animal bedding, chicken coop litter, garden mulch, covering new lawn seed, insulating a well head or a stock tank, a windbreak or an archery backstop, growing potatoes and tomatoes in straw bales, and compost once it's soiled. It's not feed, though goats and cattle will pick at it as roughage.

Can I mulch a vegetable garden with straw?

Yes, and it is my favorite mulch: a 4 to 6 inch layer holds moisture, blocks weeds and breaks down into the soil by the next season. Two cautions. Straw that was sprayed with a persistent herbicide (aminopyralid or clopyralid) will stunt and curl tomatoes, beans and potatoes, so ask the grower before you buy. And straw carries some grain seed, so expect a little wheat to sprout and pull it.

Do horses eat hay or straw?

Hay. Straw is bedding. A horse will nibble straw bedding and it does no harm as roughage, but it cannot live on it. The old line, hay is for horses, is the easiest way to keep the two straight.

How much does a bale of hay weigh?

A small two-string square bale of grass hay runs 45 to 60 lb; alfalfa 60 to 70 lb; three-string bales 100 to 125 lb. Straw bales are lighter, 35 to 50 lb, because the stems are hollow. Round bales run 800 to 1,500 lb depending on size and density.

How do I tell if hay is good?

Green color, a sweet smell, leaves still on the stems, and no dust, mold or heat when you break a bale open. Brown, dusty or musty hay was rained on or baled wet. Push your hand into the middle of a bale; if it's warm, it was baled too wet and can mold or even start a fire in the stack.

Keep going

Read nextColorado High-Elevation Vegetable GardeningHow to plan a vegetable garden for Colorado's short, high-altitude season: zones, weather, crop choices, site and soil prep, beds and frost dates.Garden and Livestock · Guide

Related to this

Membership · $49.95 per year

Everything on this site, open, and your own manual that works with no internet

When the grid goes down, this site goes with it. Membership opens every member page and every recipe from the book, hands over all thirteen field guides as PDFs, and gives you your own manual built from the pages your household uses: searchable on your phone with no internet, and printable as one binder.

  • 158member pagesopen in full, every amount and every step
  • 138compound recipesfrom the hardcover book, exact amounts. Pick any and add them to your manual
  • 13field guides304 pages of PDFs, $130 bought one at a time
  • 9military field guidesUS Army manuals cut to 66 pages and laid out to use
  • Offlineyour own manualbuilt from any page here, searchable on your phone with no internet
  • Build your own manual on this site. pick any page, recipe, chart or whole field guide and put them in your order
  • Download it and use it with no internet. it opens like an app on your phone or computer, searchable, with no power grid and no signal
  • Print it or save it as one PDF. your cover, a contents page and every page you picked, laid out for paper
  • All 138 recipes from my hardcover book. exact amounts for pool shock water purification, Lugol's iodine antiseptic, water glassing eggs, laundry powder and the rest
  • All 13 field guides, 304 pages. Stockpile Essentials, Survival Foods, Bug-Out Bag, Home Canning, Solar Power and more, to read here or download
  • 9 military field guides. Survival, First Aid, Mountaineering and the other US Army manuals, each cut to its most useful pages
  • 158 how-to pages in full. medical, hygiene, tools and repair, garden and livestock, food, water and more
  • The audit, the logbook and the checklists. all 200 audit checkpoints, saved to your account on every device

Join for $49.95 per year

  • One payment, $49.95 per year. Cancel any time and keep access to the end of the year you paid for.
  • Sign in by email. No password, and the sign-in renews itself on every visit.
  • Most of the site stays free. Membership is for the depth, the PDFs and your own offline manual.
Garden and Livestock · GuideLast reviewed 2026-09-29

Membership · $49.95 per year

Build your own manual, searchable with no internet

Save to My Manual is a member tool. Join and this page goes straight into your manual, on your phone and on paper.

One membership opens all of it

  • Every page open in full158 member pages, plus all 138 chemical compound recipes from the hardcover book to add to your own manual.
  • All 13 field guides304 pages of printable PDFs. $130 bought separately.
  • 9 military field guidesUS Army manuals cut to their most useful pages. $90 bought separately.
  • My Manual: searchable, and it works with no internetSave any page or guide, search it on your phone with no power or signal, and print it as one binder.
  • Print or save any page as a clean PDFOne press, in the field guide layout. No ads.

The 22 guides alone: $220. All of it with membership: $49.95 a year.

$49.95per year, about 14 cents a day. Cancel any time.